Top 5 Best Mattresses for Your Spare Bedroom - Inn Mattress

Hello there! This is Kevin, and you’re reading the Slumber Yard’s guide to the Top 5 Best Mattresses for Your Spare Bedroom. We’re back with another mattress best list, and today we’re focusing on the best beds for guest rooms.

Why Choose the Best Mattresses for Guest Rooms?

Not everyone has a guest room, but for those who do, you’ll want a comfortable bed for your guests. The importance of a good mattress in a guest room extends beyond comfort; it’s about hospitality, care, and leaving a lasting impression.

Comfort and Quality

The guest room often reflects the host’s thoughtfulness. Choosing the right mattress ensures your guests feel welcomed and cared for. A quality mattress provides support and comfort, ensuring a good night’s sleep. It’s not just about aesthetics; it’s about the experience.

Budget Considerations

Since you’re not sleeping on this bed every night, you probably don’t want to spend a fortune on it. Finding the right balance between quality and affordability is key. Fortunately, we’ve reviewed over 150 beds here at the Slumber Yard, so we have a good idea of the best beds for guest rooms. Investing in a good mattress doesn’t mean breaking the bank.

Versatility and Durability

A guest room mattress should be versatile enough to accommodate different sleeping preferences and durable enough to last for years. Investing in a mattress that caters to various sleeping positions and withstands wear and tear is a wise decision.

Shipping, Returns, Trial Periods, and Warranties

Before we delve into the beds themselves, let’s quickly run through all the shipping, returns, trial periods, and warranties for these beds. These factors are not just additional perks; they are essential considerations in making an informed purchase.

Free Shipping

Free shipping is not just a cost-saving feature; it’s about convenience and accessibility. It allows you to choose the best mattress without worrying about additional shipping costs.

At Least a 100-Night Trial Period

A 100-night trial period gives you ample time to test the mattress in your guest room. It’s not just about feeling the mattress in a store for a few minutes; it’s about experiencing it in the actual setting where it will be used.

Free Returns Within That Trial Period

Free returns within that trial period provide peace of mind. If the mattress doesn’t meet your expectations, you can return it without any hassle. It’s about trust and confidence in your purchase.

A 10-Year Warranty

A 10-year warranty is not just a promise; it’s a commitment to quality and durability. It assures you that the mattress is built to last and that the manufacturer stands behind their product.

Trial Period Considerations

Because of this trial period, you might want to spend a few nights sleeping in your guest room just to make sure that you think your guests will find it comfortable. A trial period is definitely more useful when it’s your every night mattress, but it’s still very consumer-friendly nonetheless. It’s about making an informed decision that aligns with your needs and expectations.

Top 5 Best Mattresses for Your Spare Bedroom

ProductMain FeaturesProsConsPrice
Tuft and Needle Mattress10-inch foam, T&N Adaptive foam, Medium firmnessBudget-friendly, Simple design, Accommodating feelMay not suit strict back sleepersAround $600
Brooklyn Bedding SignatureHybrid construction, Customizable firmness, Made in Phoenix, ArizonaComfortable, Affordable, Firmness options, Good for heavy peopleSoft model may be too soft for someAround $800-$1,000
Nectar MattressGel memory foam, Medium to medium-firm feelTraditional memory foam feel, Budget-friendly, Bundle promotionsMay feel too firm initiallyAround $800
Casper Element Mattress10-inch foam, Airscape technology, Slightly firmer than mediumBudget-friendly, Similar to Tuft and Needle, Cooling technologyMay not suit those looking for a plush feelAround $600
Allswell MattressHybrid construction, Medium-firm feel, Owned by WalmartExtremely budget-friendly, Supportive coils, Modern design, Eco-friendly optionsMay not be ideal for petite side sleepersAround $375

1. Tuft and Needle Mattress: A Comprehensive Review

Tuft and Needle Mattress
Tuft and Needle Mattress

Starting with the Tuft and Needle mattress, this is one of the most popular beds sold online in general, and that’s in large part because it’s just a safe, accommodating, and budget-friendly option. It’s a 10-inch thick foam mattress with a very simple design. But don’t let its simplicity fool you; it’s crafted with precision and attention to detail.

Construction and Materials

The Tuft and Needle mattress uses two layers of foam: a dense support foam and then a layer of their proprietary T&N Adaptive foam on top of that. This combination provides a unique balance of comfort and support.

  • Dense Support Foam: This foundational layer ensures that the mattress maintains its shape and provides the necessary support. It’s the backbone of the mattress, giving it stability.
  • T&N Adaptive Foam: This top layer is where the magic happens. It’s designed to adapt to the body’s contours, providing a soft yet supportive feel. It’s more breathable than traditional memory foam, ensuring a cooler sleep.

Firmness and Comfort

It’s around a medium on our firmness scale, which means no matter what position your guest likes to sleep in, they should be set to go on Tuft and Needle. Whether they are back sleepers, side sleepers, or stomach sleepers, this mattress caters to all.

  • Back Sleepers: The mattress provides enough support to keep the spine aligned while offering comfort to the back.
  • Side Sleepers: The adaptive foam gently cushions the shoulders and hips, reducing pressure points.
  • Stomach Sleepers: The medium firmness ensures that the hips don’t sink too deep, maintaining proper alignment.

Price and Value

One of the standout features of the Tuft and Needle mattress is its affordability without compromising quality. It’s a budget-friendly option that doesn’t cut corners. Whether you’re furnishing a guest room or looking for a reliable everyday mattress, it offers great value for money.

The Tuft and Needle mattress is more than just a popular online choice; it’s a testament to thoughtful design and quality construction. Its medium firmness and adaptive foam technology make it a versatile option suitable for various sleep preferences. Its budget-friendly price tag makes it accessible to a wide range of consumers. It’s not just a mattress; it’s a commitment to comfort and satisfaction.

2. Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress: A Detailed Analysis

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress

Next up on the list, we have the Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress. If you’re looking for a generally comfortable, affordable hybrid mattress for your guest room, this is going to be one of your best options you can find online. But what makes it stand out? Let’s delve into the details.

Brand Reputation and Manufacturing

Brooklyn Bedding, as a brand, manufactures a ton of different beds out of their facility in Phoenix, Arizona. This American-made quality is a testament to the brand’s commitment to excellence. The Signature mattress is their most popular option, and it’s not hard to see why.

Hybrid Construction

What sets the Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress apart is its hybrid construction. It combines the best of both worlds:

  • Coils: The individually wrapped coils provide support, bounce, and breathability. They ensure that the mattress adapts to the sleeper’s body, offering targeted support where needed.
  • Foams: The comfort layers of foam add a plush feel to the mattress. They work in harmony with the coils to provide a balanced sleeping experience.

Affordability Without Compromise

The Signature mattress is known for being an affordable hybrid mattress. But affordability doesn’t mean cutting corners. It offers a luxurious feel without the luxury price tag. It’s a value-driven option that doesn’t sacrifice quality.

Firmness Options

One of the unique features of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress is the choice of firmness levels. Whether you prefer soft, medium, or firm, there’s an option to suit your needs. This customization ensures that the mattress can cater to various sleeping preferences, making it an ideal choice for a guest room.

Durability and Sustainability

Built with durability in mind, the Signature mattress is designed to last. The quality materials and construction ensure that it withstands the test of time. Moreover, Brooklyn Bedding’s commitment to sustainability adds an extra layer of appeal for the eco-conscious consumer.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress is more than just a comfortable and affordable option; it’s a statement of quality and innovation. Its hybrid construction offers a balanced feel, while the choice of firmness levels adds a personalized touch. Manufactured in the USA, it carries the assurance of quality craftsmanship. Whether for a guest room or your primary sleeping space, it’s a choice that reflects discernment and taste.

3. Nectar Mattress: An In-Depth Look

Nectar Mattress
Nectar Mattress

The Nectar mattress is going to be one of your more budget-friendly memory foam options you’re going to be able to find online. It’s a name synonymous with comfort and affordability. But what makes it a standout choice? Let’s explore.

Memory Foam Comfort

A lot of sleepers out there really like that traditional feel of a memory foam bed, and Nectar is going to be just that. It’s not just about the feel; it’s about the experience. When you lay down on it, it’s going to feel pretty firm at first, but then you’re going to slowly start to sink into those top layers of gel memory foam. This sensation is more than comfort; it’s a hug for your body.

Construction and Materials

The Nectar mattress is crafted with precision, using high-quality materials:

  • Gel Memory Foam: The top layers are infused with gel, providing a cooling effect. It contours to your body, offering personalized comfort.
  • Supportive Base Foam: This layer ensures that the mattress maintains its shape and provides the necessary support.

Firmness and Feel

The Nectar mattress offers a unique firmness profile. Initially, it may feel firm, but as the memory foam warms to your body, it softens, providing a balanced feel. It’s a journey from firm support to gentle cradling, making it suitable for various sleeping positions.

Affordability and Value

What sets Nectar apart is its affordability without compromising on quality. It’s a budget-friendly option that offers the luxurious feel of memory foam. It’s a testament to the brand’s commitment to delivering value.

Trial Period and Warranty

Nectar goes above and beyond with its generous trial period and warranty. With a risk-free trial and a robust warranty, it’s a purchase made with confidence.

Eco-Friendly Considerations

Nectar’s commitment to sustainability is reflected in its eco-friendly materials and manufacturing processes. It’s a choice that’s not just good for you but also good for the planet.

The Nectar mattress is more than a budget-friendly memory foam option; it’s a statement of comfort, quality, and responsible consumerism. Its unique feel, quality construction, and affordability make it a standout choice for those seeking the traditional memory foam experience with a modern twist. Whether for a guest room or your primary sleeping space, the Nectar mattress offers a sleep experience that’s both comforting and reassuring.

4. Casper Element Mattress: A Comprehensive Review

Casper Element Mattress
Casper Element Mattress

Next up on the list, we have the Casper Element mattress. Casper, as a brand, is one of the most recognizable names in online beds, and the Element mattress is designed to be their most budget-friendly option. But what makes it a compelling choice? Let’s dive in.

Design and Construction

The Casper Element’s design is very similar to Tuft and Needle, and it’s also a 10-inch foam bed with two layers of foam: a support foam and a comfort foam. Here’s a closer look:

  • Support Foam: This foundational layer provides the necessary support and stability. It ensures that the mattress maintains its shape over time.
  • Comfort Foam: The top layer is crafted to provide a plush and comfortable sleeping experience. It contours to the body, offering a gentle cradle.

Airscape Technology

One of the standout features of the Casper Element is the Airscape technology. This consists of small perforations in the foam that enhance airflow, helping to regulate temperature. It’s a subtle innovation that adds to the overall comfort.

Firmness and Feel

The Casper Element offers a balanced firmness level. It’s designed to cater to a wide range of sleepers, offering a medium feel that’s neither too soft nor too firm. It’s a versatile choice that accommodates various sleeping positions.

Affordability and Value

As Casper’s most budget-friendly option, the Element mattress provides exceptional value for money. It offers the quality and comfort associated with the Casper brand at a more accessible price point.

Eco-Friendly Considerations

Casper’s commitment to sustainability is reflected in the Element mattress. The materials are certified for environmental friendliness, adding an extra layer of appeal for the eco-conscious consumer.

Trial Period and Warranty

With a generous trial period and a robust warranty, the Casper Element offers peace of mind with your purchase. It’s a testament to the brand’s confidence in their product.

The Casper Element mattress is more than just an affordable option; it’s a well-crafted, comfortable, and innovative choice. Its design, Airscape technology, balanced firmness, and eco-friendly considerations make it a standout option in the budget-friendly category. Whether for a guest room or your primary sleeping space, the Casper Element is a reflection of quality and thoughtful design, all at a price that doesn’t break the bank.

5. Allswell Mattress: A Budget-Friendly Marvel

Allswell Mattress
Allswell Mattress

Last but not least, we have the Allswell mattress. In the world of online mattresses, Allswell stands out as a game-changer, especially when it comes to pricing. Let’s explore why this mattress is making waves.

Unbeatable Pricing

We are consistently surprised by the pricing of this mattress. For a queen size, you can pick it up for only 375 bucks, and it will regularly go on discount to bring that price down even more. It’s pretty crazy that such pricing is usually reserved for all foam beds you can buy on Amazon, but Allswell is actually owned by Walmart. This ownership allows for a competitive edge in pricing without compromising quality.

Hybrid Construction

Unlike many budget options, the Allswell mattress is a hybrid construction, combining the best of both foam and coils. Here’s a breakdown:

  • Support Coils: The base layer of individually wrapped coils provides robust support and adds a bounce that many sleepers prefer.
  • Comfort Foam: Above the coils, a layer of memory foam offers contouring and comfort, ensuring a plush sleeping experience.

Firmness and Feel

The Allswell mattress offers a medium-firm feel, making it suitable for a wide range of sleepers. Whether you’re a back, side, or stomach sleeper, the Allswell can accommodate your needs.

Sleek Design and Aesthetics

With a modern and sleek design, the Allswell mattress is not just about functionality; it’s also about aesthetics. The quality craftsmanship and attention to detail make it a visually appealing addition to any bedroom.

Eco-Friendly Options

Allswell is committed to sustainability, offering eco-friendly options within their product line. It’s a consideration that adds value for the environmentally conscious consumer.

Warranty and Customer Support

Backed by Walmart’s reputation, Allswell offers excellent customer support and a generous warranty. It’s a testament to the brand’s confidence in their product and commitment to customer satisfaction.

The Allswell mattress is a remarkable offering in the budget-friendly category. Its hybrid construction, unbeatable pricing, sleek design, and eco-friendly options make it a standout choice. Owned by Walmart and committed to quality, Allswell is redefining what it means to offer a budget-friendly mattress without cutting corners. It’s a choice that delivers on both comfort and value, making it a wise investment for anyone seeking quality sleep without the hefty price tag.


That’s going to wrap up our list of the Top 5 Best Mattresses for Your Spare Bedroom. This was a pretty tough list to put together because we’ve reviewed a lot of affordable, accommodating mattresses, but we think if you pick any of these five beds, your guests are going to be sleeping happy in your house. If this article helps you out at all, give it a thumbs up, and as always, sleep right, sleep tight, and we’ll see you next time.

Pin It